Meet the future: the plant-based, lab-grown meat industry of tomorrow
Towards the end of 2017, technology wunderkint Ben Pasternak sold his social media app, Monkey, to a Chinese company and set off in pursuit of his next project. In July 2019, Pasternak officially launched his latest venture: Nuggs.
Pasternak and his newly assembled team - which includes 20-year-old Liam Mullen, a self-taught molecular gastronomist who worked at Michelin Star restaurant Daniel as a pastry chef at the age of 16 as his Head of Product - are stepping into an increasingly cutthroat and competitive arena. According to Barclays, the global market for alternative meat products “could reach $140bn” in the next decade, capturing around 10% of the global market for meat.
Competitive and potentially lucrative, the meat-free meat market already boasts several established players who have begun to define the parameters of the playing field. Here’s our breakdown of the biggest players in the space, and our analysis of where the cutting edge of food innovation could take us in the next decade.
The First Generation - Beyond Meat and Impossible Foods
Frequent recipients of high-profile coverage, plant-based burger manufacturers Beyond Meat and Impossible Foods have both had some of the most vibrant financial years of any startups. Los Angeles-based Beyond Meat went public in May 2019, with an impressive post-IPO valuation of $3.8bn. Even more impressive is that, since then, the company’s stock remains more than 200% above its $25 IPO price.
A high profile deal with Subway will see Beyond Meat’s new vegan meatballs begin to be served up in September. Speaking of high-profile deals, the biggest step towards the normalization of vegan meat alternatives (besides UK snack shop Greggs’ spectacularly infamous sausage roll debut, which drove company profits up by 58%) taken this year was Impossible Foods’ distribution deal with fast food giant Burger King. According to a Guardian report, “Impossible Foods introduced the burger as the veggie patty that “bleeds” at the high-end New York restaurant Momofuku in 2016. The burger is a feat of food engineering, attaining its red color from genetically modified yeast.” The Impossible Whopper debuted in the US last week and demand is reportedly already outpacing supply.
As the two new giants vie to be the face of the premium plant-based meat alternative market, a slew of challengers are pouring into the space, hungry for success.
Cutting edge nugget technology - Nuggs
With a business development background that’s more app than snack, Pasternak plans to use his technology pedigree to his advantage as Nuggs attempts to carve out a place for itself in an already crowded market.
The company operates similar to a technology startup, with Pasternak taking a unique approach to product development. Much like an app, Nuggs will release updates to its nuggets as the formula is constantly improved upon in response to user feedback, according to a recent press release.
The New York startup’s approach is evident in the language used by the company. “Nuggs will disrupt the animal-based meat industry with its new nugget technology.” Nuggs are a more advanced version of the animal-based chicken nuggets that have dominated the market for decades. After over a year of research and development, Nuggs has developed a nugget that uses an advanced texturized pea protein technology to create a nugget with the best texture, crunch and taste.” A technological approach from a technology prodigy, applied to one of the world’s favorite unhealthy snacks. "Nuggs is the intersection of food and the internet," said Pasternak. "We set out to make the best nugget period, a chicken nugget simulation is just the baseline."
Nuggs raised $7mn in an initial funding round led by food production giant McCain Foods. "At McCain we believe Nuggs has developed an incredible product that uses plant based technology to uniquely simulate a high quality chicken nugget,” commented McCain’s Chief Growth Officer, Mauro Pennella.
The future of "farming" - Future Meat Technologies and Memphis Meats
Speaking of growth, as futuristic as Nuggs’ approach to strategy and “nugget technology” may be, the work being done by challenger startups Future Meat Technologies and Memphis Meats steps directly out of the pages of Kurd Lasswitz and Douglas Adams (although we have yet to create meat that can express which parts of itself are the most delicious).
Earlier this week, Jan Dutkiewicz noted, in a new piece for The Jacobin, that “the number of vegans and self-proclaimed flexitarians may slowly be growing, but on balance, animal rights activists’ and environmentalists’ pleas have done little to change the public’s appetite for meat. The average American eats about 220 pounds of animal flesh per year.”
In order to sate the public desire for meat, while overcoming the environmental and logistical issues posed by meat farming and consumption, Future Food Technologies and Memphis Meats are working to advance the science of growing animal flesh from cell cultures in a lab.
Founded in 2015 by Uma and Nicholas Genovese, Memphis Meats is building “food from the ground up.” The company is located in Berkeley, California and counts food giant Cargill grain company, Richard Branson and Bill Gates among its investors.
Based in Jerusalem, Future Meat Technologies is also working to make animal-free meat production a reality. The biotech startup, like Nuggs and Memphis Meats, has the mighty power of a food production behind it. Arkansas-headquartered Tyson Foods, one of the largest food producers in the world pledged $2.2mn to the company in 2018.
The widespread investment in animal-free meat and plant-based alternatives that taste as good as they are for the planet is, it has been pointed out, nothing to do with major food companies’ misty-eyed conversion to veganism. The global meat market is worth $1.4trn and, with the rising popular demand for more environmentally sustainable alternatives, meatless meat could become one of the fastest-growing cash cows in the world.
Future-tech and IXAfrica: Full Life Cycle Expertise
Future-tech is unique among data centre consultancies for a number of reasons. Not only does the Reading-based firm have high levels of expertise in markets ranging from Helsinki to Johannesburg, but Future-tech offers services across the complete life cycle of a facility.
“We are involved with projects from the initiation to completion,” explains James Wilman, Future-tech’s CEO. “We go from initiation phase - which could mean the site selection process or technical due diligence for a merger or acquisition - all the way through establishing the brief, the various design stages, construction oversight, commissioning, operation, end of life cycle replenishment, and can start right back at the beginning with refurbishment.”
While some factors, like the facility requirements for major tenants, remain the same no matter where you are, Wilman explains that “it's the environmental conditions, construction methodologies, supply chain, and skill sets available in different locations that vary, and that makes this a very interesting job.”
Future-tech was selected by IXAfrica as the life cycle design strategic partner for its hyperscale campus project in Nairobi, Kenya. Wilman explains that, over the past year, Future-tech has been leveraging its strong local knowledge, working closely with Kenyan architects and engineers, and collaborating with both Guy Wilner and Clement Martineau, to help IXAfrica successfully deliver Kenya’s largest hyperscale data centre.
“Future-tech did its first project on the African continent in 2012 in Kenya. I've been involved in the data centre space there for a long time, and have known Guy for a number of years through projects and interaction in Europe,” says Wilman. “As the IXAfrica project came into being, Guy and I spoke about it as he knew that we were already quite familiar with the area. We assisted out with the initial planning and project design, and the relationship really grew from there.”
Wilman adds that the experience helping Future-tech support the IXAfrica project has been hard-won. “It's been a steep learning curve, figuring out how to work in Africa. Some of our earlier projects were quite challenging, but we're fortunate to be at a point now where working throughout the region feels really comfortable,” he explains. “One of the things about Nairobi - which we found out when we were working on our first project in the city back in 2012 - is that, because it's about 1,200 metres above sea level, the altitude actually de-rates the onsite equipment. Having your equipment perform less well because of the altitude can massively impact the whole facility.” Understanding the factors that define a local environment can be the difference between success and disaster for a data centre, and Future-tech’s extensive experience in Kenya is a key supporting factor for IXAfrica’s success in Nairobi.
Wilman has also developed a strong collaborative relationship with Guy and Clement. “We've got over a gigawatt of design projects going through our office at the moment with different clients, which means that we're always learning new things. What is refreshing about working with Guy and Clement is that when we bring them a new idea, they listen to us,” says Wilman. “We've had a good run in Nairobi with IXAfrica built off of a long relationship, and I hope we get to continue working with them on their future projects.”